You will see in
the photos that I have not retained the original meter shunts. I
began my career in a calibration lab. So I check and often remove or
trim the values of the original shunts if they are not accurate to
better than 5%. The wire shunts EFJ uses do not lend themselves to
calibration well, and are nearly impossible to solder to. Copious
amounts of flux and heat are required. Generally they are way off
calibration. My rig on RF plate was over 20% off. The Grid meter
reading was also way off calibration. Due to the common availability
of accurate low value resistors these days, I have no reservation
about hacking these out and ditching them for better calibration. It
is very difficult to directly measure the low ohm resistors. The end
result of accurate current readings is easy to achieve without
specialized four lead ohm meters. I was unable to convince a friend
to do it this way after lengthy discussion. I suspect he got inferior
results and wasted much time the other way. A small variable supply
or 12 volt supply and variable resistor are all that is needed to get
the panel meter to 1% if you wish using a modern digital meter. These
tests are done with the Valiant unplugged from the AC power. Simulate
the current in the circuit with a power supply with a digital
milliameter and current limiting resistor in the lead and observe the
panel meter. The Valiant should be in the normal horizontal position
to avoid gravity effects on the Valiant panel meter. This is really
important to do before you attempt any modifications. Think about it.
If your plate meter reads high, and your output power is low, are you
really running rated input power? Bad data does not help you tune up
your rig properly.
.
|
Click on the thumbnail picture to see the plate meter shunt highlighted in green, and the grid meter shunt
highlighted in blue. |
The formulas will get you
close, but make the final adjustment with a power supply, appropriate
series resistor to limit the current, and an accurate digital current
meter. If you have a 500 mA commercial wall wart with a voltage
adjustment switch that can be set to 12 Volts and a series resistor
that can be set to slightly more than 27 Ohms (at 6 Watts or more),
you have what you need to calibrate the 0.202 Ohm Plate meter shunt
resistor for 450 mA full scale. Clearly, a variable power supply with
an LM317 that runs off your 12 Volt station supply will be easier to
adjust to full scale. The same 12 Volt wall wart can be used with a
series resistor of slightly more than 500 Ohms at half a watt to
calibrate the Grid current meter of 25 mA full scale. To calibrate
the Modulator meter 0.404 Ohm shunt, you will need the same 12 Volt
wall wart and a slightly more than 50 Ohm series resistor to limit
the current to 0.250 mA full scale. During this process, be sure to
apply the current to the points in the circuit that generate the
actual current being measured, not parts of the shunt resistor. It is
also important to realize that the RF plate meter and the modulation
meter are NOT referenced directly to chassis ground! Do NOT put your
test supply clip leads to the chassis when calibrating the panel
meter. Look at the E F Johnson schematic to be sure where to make the
connections, or your calibration will not turn out right.
If the panel
meter reads lower than the digital meter used to calibrate it, a
resistor must be inserted in series with the multiplier resistor in
the Valiant. This is pretty straightforward. Increase the value of
the Valiant resistor by 1% if the meter reads 1% low.
If the analog
panel meter reads higher than the digital calibration meter, a shunt
resistor is required across the existing resistor to reduce its
value. It is definitely easier to start with a larger resistor and
trim it down from the standpoint of circuit connections. You can just
touch the intended trim resistor across the existing one to try it
out to see if it is about right. If not, try the next closest value.
Here are some
helpful rule of thumb approximations if the meter reads high:
If the meter
reads 20% high, put a shunt resistor across the multiplier resistor 5
times the value of the multiplier resistor and the panel meter.
If the meter reads 10% high,
put a shunt resistor across the multiplier resistor 10 times the
value of the multiplier resistor and the panel meter.
If the meter reads 5% high,
put a shunt resistor across the multiplier resistor 20 times the
value of the multiplier resistor and the panel meter.
If the meter reads 2% high,
put a shunt resistor across the multiplier resistor 50 times the
value of the multiplier resistor and the panel meter.
If the meter reads 1% high,
put a shunt resistor across the multiplier resistor 100 times the
value of the multiplier resistor and the panel meter.
This process can be done
repetitively to approach the value with higher and higher shunt
calibration resistors until you get as close as you wish.
If you need to fix the RF
plate or Modulator multiplier resistors, the best way is to hack out
the original resistance wire loop and replace them with a real
precision resistor which is cheap and commonly available. Get one
slightly higher than the 0.404 or 0.202 ohm values specified by EFJ
for the RF and Modulator Plate Current shunts and trim them down by
the methods shown above.
If you wish to use math,
here are the formulas you need. Keep in mind that these will only
adjust for the theoretical accuracy of the resistor specified in the
Johnson parts list. If the meter movement is off a bit, the method
described above is better because it adjusts the actual meter
reading, not just the resistor. I argued with someone on the air for
half an hour about why this was the best way before I gave up.
Measuring the resistor is an INDIRECT method that assumes the panel
meter is accurate. Measuring the actual current is a DIRECT method,
since it assumes nothing, and corrects for any errors in the meter
movement and switch and wiring resistance. The only possible source
of error is the digital test meter used to calibrate the transmitter
panel meter. Use the calculations to get you in the ballpark and do
the final adjustment with a digital meter and power supply.
The resistors are defined
as:
Rt = the total resistance
shunt desired, such as 0.202 Ohms
R1 = the first standard
value resistor, such as 0.27 Ohms
R2 = the parallel resistance
to be added across R1 to obtain Rt
General formula for total
parallel resistance of R1 and R2:
(Inverse of the sum of the
inverses)
Specific formula for total
resistance with only two paralleled resistors R1 and R2:
(Product over sum)
Specific formula to find the
necessary parallel resistance R2 to lower a standard value resistor
R1 to a desired total meter shunt theoretical value Rt:
(Product over difference)
Specific example of 0.27 Ohm
standard value starting resistor to get a final value of 0.202 Ohms
using Product over Difference formula (two iterations):
R2 |
= |
RTR1 |
= |
.27 × .202 |
= |
.0545 |
= |
.802+ |
R1 − RT |
.27 − .202 |
.068 |
To obtain a 0.8 ohm resistor, begin with a 1 ohm resistor.
Using the rule of thumb, to reduce the resistance by 20%, use a parallel resistor of 5× the
value. Five times one ohm is five ohms, or 4.7 ohm nearest standard value.
SOLUTION: Use 0.27 ohms, 1 ohm, and 4.7 ohms in parallel.
THis results in less than 1% error in the value of the meter shunt resistance. Again, I caution you
that this is an indirect method that does not account for any inaccuracies from the analog panel
meter movement or stray resistance in the meter switch and associated wiring. The final calibration
should be done as described above with a power supply, current-limiting resistor, and digital
meter of sufficient accuracy to ensure results which meet your standards.
RECOMMENDED READING:
Metering amplifier or transmitter
from W8JI.
|